The short answer
Ask for about 10% off the vacant possession price. In our worked example, 10% off beat the vacant purchase on net yield in all three first-year scenarios. Those scenarios include a tribunal challenge and the tenant moving out.
A 5% discount works only if the tenant stays and accepts the rise. You need 15% when the rent sits about 25% below market and the next increase lies a year away. Even then, 15% only matches the vacant purchase in year one.
The reason sits in the rules. Since 1 May 2026, the Renters' Rights Act decides how fast you can close the gap to market rent. The discount has to pay for that wait.
What a new owner can and cannot do since 1 May 2026
A sale leaves the tenancy intact. The tenant keeps the same rent, deposit and rights, and you take over the seller's position on completion.
Since 1 May 2026, a landlord can raise the rent only through the section 13 process. GOV.UK sets out the rules:
- One increase a year. The next rise cannot take effect until a year after the last one.
- At least two months' notice on Form 4A. Rent review clauses no longer work.
- The tenant can refer the notice to the First-tier Tribunal. The tribunal cannot set a rent above your figure.
- A tribunal rent starts from the decision date, with no backdating. For undue hardship the tribunal can delay it by up to two months.
- The tenant can end the tenancy at any time with two months' written notice.
Tribunal waits matter here. Ministry of Justice data reported in July 2026 put the median time from application to decision at about 13 weeks. Gowling WLG counted 166 market rent decisions in July 2026, against 44 a year earlier.
Ground 1A lets a landlord recover possession to sell, with four months' notice. Its 12-month bar runs from the start of the tenancy. Your purchase date does not restart that clock. So a buyer of a two-year-old tenancy could serve ground 1A notice in the first week.
That route only helps an exit. After a ground 1A notice, you cannot re-let or market the home until 12 months after the notice ends. Shelter notes fines of up to £40,000 for breaking that rule. If the tenancy started less than a year ago, you wait for the anniversary before any notice can expire. In practice, you buy the tenant's rent and the tenant's timetable.
Worked example: a £220,000 terrace in Salford
Take Sam, a hypothetical investor looking at a two-bed terrace in Salford. With vacant possession, it would sell for £220,000 and let for £1,250 a month. The sitting tenant pays £1,050, 16% below market. Her tenancy began in April 2024, and her last rise took effect on 1 April 2026.
Sam completes on 1 December 2026. Her earliest new rent date falls on 1 April 2027. She serves Form 4A by 31 January 2027 and proposes £1,250. Our assumptions:
- Mortgage at 75% loan to value, interest-only, at 5.7%. Moneyfacts put the average five-year fixed buy-to-let rate at 75% LTV at 5.66% on 1 August 2026.
- Stamp duty at the higher rates for additional homes, plus £2,500 for legal fees and a survey.
- Running costs: 12% of rent for management, £450 insurance, £1,500 for repairs and safety certificates.
- The vacant buyer loses one month to find a tenant and pays a £600 letting fee.
- From year two, both properties let at £1,250, with a 3% void allowance.
We measure net yield as rent after running costs, divided by price plus stamp duty and fees. Cash-on-cash takes off mortgage interest and divides by the deposit plus costs.
The vacant purchase costs £235,400 in total. It earns a 4.06% net yield in year one and 4.61% once let. Steady-state cash-on-cash comes to 2.06%, because 5.7% interest swallows most of the rent.
Year one: three ways the tenancy can play out
We ran three paths for the sitting tenant. If she accepts the rise, Sam collects £14,200 in year one. If she goes to the tribunal and the new rent starts on 1 July 2027, Sam collects £13,600. If she gives notice and leaves at the end of March, the home sits empty for a month. Sam then re-lets at £1,250 from May, collects £12,950 and pays a £600 fee.
Here are the net yields for each discount, in the order accept, tribunal, leaves:
- 5% off (£209,000, total cost £223,630): 4.72%, 4.48%, 3.96%. Steady state 4.85%, cash-on-cash 2.87%.
- 10% off (£198,000, total cost £211,860): 4.98%, 4.73%, 4.18%. Steady state 5.12%, cash-on-cash 3.77%.
- 15% off (£187,000, total cost £200,090): 5.27%, 5.01%, 4.42%. Steady state 5.42%, cash-on-cash 4.78%.
- Vacant (£220,000, total cost £235,400): 4.06% in year one. Steady state 4.61%, cash-on-cash 2.06%.
At 5% off, Sam falls behind the vacant buyer if the tenant leaves. At 10% off, she stays ahead in every path. The lower price also cuts her stamp duty by £1,540 and her annual interest by £941.
Tax widens the gap. From 6 April 2027, property income tax rates rise to 22%, 42% and 47%, with finance cost relief at 22%. For a basic-rate taxpayer, steady-state cash after tax reaches £1,864 a year at 10% off. The vacant buyer keeps £1,130. A higher-rate taxpayer loses money on both: about £307 a year at 10% off and £1,041 vacant.
Where the numbers break
Change two inputs and the picture shifts. Suppose the tenant pays £950, 24% below market. Her last rise took effect in November 2026, so the next cannot land before November 2027. The tribunal then settles at £1,200.
Sam now earns £950 a month for the whole first year. Her year-one net yield falls to 3.61% at 5% off, 3.81% at 10% and 4.04% at 15%. Only the 15% discount roughly matches the vacant buyer's 4.06%. From year two, at £1,200, the yields recover to 4.62%, 4.88% and 5.17%.
Three more risks sit outside the spreadsheet. First, the tribunal cap cuts both ways. Propose too little on Form 4A and you lock it in untill the next annual rise. Second, a sitting tenant means no viewing of every room before exchange. Budget for repairs you could not see.
Third, the discount only turns into equity if you later sell with vacant possession. Sell with the tenant in place, and the next buyer will ask for the same discount. Treat the exit as a separate decision, with ground 1A's four months' notice and 12-month re-letting ban in the plan.
Checklist before you agree a price
- Get the date of the last rent rise in writing. It fixes your first Form 4A date.
- Price the gap to market rent from achieved rents on comparable lettings.
- Check the tenancy start date. Under 12 months means ground 1A notice cannot expire yet.
- Ask for the deposit protection certificate, gas and electrical certificates, and proof the seller gave the government's Information Sheet.
- Review 12 months of rent payments for arrears.
- Check the vacant valuation against sold property prices for the street, not asking prices.
- Confirm your lender accepts a purchase with an existing tenant, and how it treats the current rent.
- After completion, sign up to HM Land Registry's free Property Alert. It emails you when someone applies to sell or mortgage the home.
For Sam, the answer came out at 10%. That figure covers a slow tribunal and a tenant who walks away. If the rent gap tops 20% or the next rise lies a year off, hold out for 15%.
Where Torquity fits
Torquity estimates market rent from comparable lettings and shows a confidence range. That lets you size the gap to the sitting tenant's rent. It also calculates net yield, DSCR and cash-on-cash. Run the vacant price and your discounted offer through it before you make an offer.
How we wrote this
Liza Herman, Research and Marketing at Torquity, wrote this article with AI assistance in drafting. Rules come from GOV.UK guidance on rent increases and grounds for possession (updated 1 May 2026). We checked Housing Act 1988 Schedule 2 on legislation.gov.uk (current to 27 October 2026). Shelter England's legal guidance on section 13 and ground 1A added detail (October 2026). Mortgage rates come from Moneyfacts (1 August 2026). Tax figures come from GOV.UK stamp duty rates and HMRC's policy paper on April 2027 property income rates. Tribunal data comes from Ministry of Justice figures reported by Landlord Studio and Gowling WLG (2026). Rent data comes from the ONS release of 21 October 2026. The worked example uses Torquity's assumptions and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice.